| Three Murfreesboro Police officers disciplined |
|
By: Lisa Marchesoni
|
Posted: Wednesday, January 27, 2010 9:41 am
|
Email Print
|
Three Murfreesboro Police supervisors were disciplined for their roles in a female officer’s complaint about gender discrimination.
Officer Erica Brinkley complained Sgt. Shawn Murphy discriminated against her based on her gender during a meeting Nov. 18 with City Attorney Susan Emery McGannon.
A committee of five city supervisors investigated and found Murphy did not discriminate against Brinkley but found his conduct by using profanity and his demeanor of intimidating behavior violated city policy. They interviewed the three supervisors, Brinkley and 13 other officers.
Also, the committee found Lt. Tom Sissom and Sgt. Garry Carter failed to notify the personnel director about Brinkley’s complaints.
Police Chief Glenn Chrisman issued a written reprimand against Murphy last week and ordered he receive remedial training in supervision and leadership, remedial training in obscene language and conduct and undergo stress management training.
Chrisman placed Sissom on two days suspension without pay and on probation on year. He was ordered to receive remedial training on contacting the personnel director with complaints of discrimination and to receive remedial training in supervision, management and leadership.
The chief issued a written reprimand against Carter and ordered him to receive remedial training on contacting the personnel director with complaints of discrimination and to receive remedial training in supervision, management and leadership.
In her complaint, Brinkley alleged she was discriminated by Murphy against on the following complaints of different treatment of males in:
• Scrutinizing of traffic reports.
• Using a red pen to highlight inaccuracies in reports.
• Making vulgar, threatening remarks toward her.
• Burning a corner of a report.
• Wearing mirrored sunglasses.
• Transferring her to different sections of the city for her work assignment.
Also, Brinkley reported Sissom responded to her complaint of a hostile work environment by stating she could speak to another sergeant.
She reported during the Nov. 11, 2009 roll call Murphy cursed and ordered officers not give reports to another supervisor or “I’m going to take those reports and shove them up you’re a--.”
Murphy said he returned a crash report to Brinkley because it was not correct. She had her husband, Officer Curtis Brinkley, turn in the report to another sergeant, which angered Murphy. He denied his comments were directed at Brinkley.
Carter said he believed Murphy indirectly made the comment about Brinkley. Both male and female officers are intimidated about how Murphy scrutinizes their reports so they turn in reports to him. He said Sissom is aware of this but did not respond.
Sissom said Murphy’s comments were not appropriate and counseled with him. He moved Brinkley to be supervised by another sergeant. Also, Sissom said he made a mistake in not communicating complaints of discrimination to the personnel director.
The committee found Sissom “exacerbated the problems between Murphy and many patrol officers by requiring officers to turn their reports into another sergeant and by reassigning patrol officers to another zone when friction developed between the patrol officers and Sgt. Murphy.”
Also, the commit stated “Murphy’s management style, his pattern of yelling at employees, his use of profanity, his use of terms of endearment and speaking to other officers with an intimidating voice leaves some employees to feel bullied or ridiculed, this violating the city’s fair treatment policy.”
|
|
|
|
|
|
Member Opinions:
By:
willis5038 on 1/27/10
Wow. Maybe someone needs to take their delicate sensibilities to different line of work. I can't believe that she really listed "wearing mirrored sunglasses" as a form of intimidation. Ridiculous!
By:
TN-popo on 1/27/10
Agreed. Sounds like there are some issues on both sides.
Gave her report to her husband to turn in? Sheesh.
By:
ebbabc on 1/27/10
Using a red pen is intimidating? What rubbish!
I think this officer is too thin skinned and in the wrong profession.
What does scrutining mean?
By:
attagirl on 1/27/10
I am sure there are policies regarding wearing sunglasses and apparently her supervisor violated the policy. Same for correcting her reports. If he's only after her with the red pen, and no other officers doing the same thing she's doing, then the supervisor is wrong.
Considering that the officers were disciplined for their conduct, it sounds like this female officer had legitimate complaints.
By:
momof3 on 1/27/10
If she is this big a baby over these ridiculous allegations, what is she going to do when there really are issues? I agree she needs to find a new line of work or isolate herself somewhere. Harrassment and intimidation go on in a lot of lines of work and you either put up with it or you find a different job. She should be glad she has a job at all. Years ago, when I worked at a police dept. (I won't say which one), females were subjected to being grabbed or touched in inappropriate places, dirty/sexual jokes were told in their presence and they were openly propositioned and suggestive remarks were made routinely. They had to put up with it or quit. Complaints to higher ups didn't do any good because they were involved too or part of the good ol' boy system where their friends didn't get in trouble. THAT was intimidation and harrassment, not seeing your reflection in mirrored sunglasses!
By:
truthandjustice1 on 1/27/10
OMG.. can't we all just get along.
By:
postfan on 1/27/10
She needs to pack her things and go. Do criminals on the street curse her and intimidate her too? Can she file a complaint on them? FIND A NEW JOB!!! Mirrored sunglasses???? COME ON!!!!
By:
josef on 1/27/10
WOW! Is sounds that from most of these opinions you think that verbal and sexual herrassment is OK, and if you can't take it the RECEIVER of the harrassment should just move on or just suck it up.
MOMOF3, you ESPECIALLY should know that on the job harrassment is demeaning and WRONG! How do you know these allegations are, in your words "ridiculous"? No, I was not there either...Yet it sounds like you did nother but "turn the other cheek", so to speak.
I agree there are many who CLAIM harrassment but we all know that POLE-ice ossiffers are some of the worst offenders!
By:
attagirl on 1/27/10
Shame on you, momof3. You actually said that a woman should just put up with the harassment and be glad she's got a job!
No, she shouldn't! No one should put up with workplace harassment. She did exactly as she should have done - SHE PUT A STOP TO IT. And you should have put a stop to it when it happened in your workplace.
By:
willis5038 on 1/27/10
josef, Why are police officers some of the worst offenders?
By:
postfan on 1/27/10
"A committee of five city supervisors investigated and found Murphy did not discriminate against Brinkley but found his conduct by using profanity and his demeanor of intimidating behavior violated city policy."
According to the article there was NO DISCRIMINATION or harrassment against the officer...His behavior violated policy which is why he was disciplined I presume.
By:
drnitemare on 1/27/10
I have always liked Murphy. He's always seemed to be a good guy. I have a lot of police friends and they all say a few bad words every now and then. But out of all the police we have, Officer Yates is about the best officer that anyone could ever ask for.
By:
murfreesboromommy on 1/28/10
willis5038....being that I was married to a M'boro police officer I would agree with josef. There are a couple officers that go to Dugger's on the weekend have them a few beers then get in their cars and drive home. I even had one come to my house drinking a beer while he was driving when he pulled in my driveway. Did my ex-husband say anything??? Nope! Then you have the ones that beat their wives and they get a slap on the wrist. I'll stop at that because I could keep going and going... What kills me is that they think they can get away with anything and everything just because they have that badge.
By:
gotitans2007 on 1/28/10
I am a female...so IF I choose to work in a male dominated field, I better be able to handle it and do the job equally. I wouldn't be a female fire fighter and complain about having to do everything the male fire dudes are required to do...do your job well and there shouldn't be any problems. I get a little irritated at women wanting to be equal but whining about small stuff. You lose credibility...watch the movie G.I. Jane!
By:
tennesseemur on 1/28/10
Hey where did my opinion go?
By:
vdanr on 1/28/10
Mirrored sunglasses??? Give me a break!! Does that mean we can say we feel intimidated if an officer stops us for whatever reason and he/she does not take off their mirrored sunglasses when they are talking to us??
By:
fortherecord1234567 on 1/28/10
They interviewed the three supervisors, Brinkley and 13 OTHER OFFICERS. Its possible that the complaints listed are not all from her and maybe from the OTHER 13 OFFICERS, BUT it is the POST so NO mistakes could have been made.... YEAH RIGHT! Whose the other 13 by the way? I do agree that some of the complaints listed are pretty silly, but only the auther that wrote the book can explain the true meaning of the story.
(Give praise to those who will stand up and fight... but BOO to the Dogs that bark with no bite.)Don't complain about things if you wont stand up for your complaint, just sit in the corner and keep your mouth shut!
By:
Bluesman on 1/28/10
Don't our Officers know they can be replaced by a traffic camera!
By:
Boo on 1/29/10
Did it ever occur to people that the fact that these "bad apples" are bad has nothing to do with the badge, that they were rotten before they got the badge? RCPD and MPD do a great job of weeding them out. gotitans2007- I agree!!
By:
murfreesboromommy on 1/29/10
They do not do a great job of weeding them out. There are a few "bad apples" that I could name that are with the MPD that have absolutely no business being an officer. All they do is put them off the streets for a few days or weeks in the office to do "desk duty" and back out on the streets they go!
By:
truthandjustice1 on 1/30/10
murfreesboromommy, you no doubt have a problem, seems your ex must have pissed you off, however; I am sure while you were married you were right in the middle of all this bad stuff you say is going on, your just mad because you can't run with the boys in blue anymore...where is there a problem with officers having a life, they are humans too and have all the same problems we all have. If there are really bad officers out there I hope the get caught but, if you know something perhaps you need to be calling the Chief of Police and let him know what you say you know or zip it.
Login and voice your opinion!