• Sidebar Ads




Teacher's union concerned over vouchers


 Related Articles
Email Print

As lawmakers in Tennessee consider a couple of proposals on school vouchers, the state's teachers are urging rejection over a variety of concerns.

According to the Tennessee Education Association, one issue with vouchers is that private schools are not required to accept all students, nor do they have to offer services for those with special needs.

Gera Summerford, who serves as president of the TEA, said there needs to be equal opportunity for all students, and with vouchers that won't happen.

"I heard a parent speak recently who, both of her two children - one of whom is intellectually gifted and one of whom is intellectually challenged - and she just really has trouble with the idea that a school could actually recruit one of her children and deny access to the other," Summerford said. "Again, that's one of those accountability issues that the private schools don't currently have to meet."

Among those in support of vouchers is state Rep. Joe Carr (R-Murfreesboro), who said parents should be able to use tax dollars to send their children to private schools.

"We're trying to give the parents the option," he said, "which is basically, 'Take your kid somewhere else, but use that tax money.'"

Summerford said allowing some to use vouchers to go to a private institution would divert funding away from public schools, which are there to serve everyone.

"We pay taxes in order to provide services that benefit everyone," she said, "and I don't have the right to say, 'Well, I don't want my money to pay for paving that particular road or supporting that particular state park.' We pay taxes for the good of the whole, for the good of our community and that's what public schools are all about, is serving everyone."

Summerford said there's no evidence that voucher students perform any better than their public school peers.

More information is online at teateachers.org.

 
 
 
Tagged under  Education, Politics, TEA, Tennessee Education Association, TNNS, Vouchers


Member Opinions:
By: chg_mtsu_s13 on 3/8/13
Chg2j_mtsu_s13
Honestly, this is a very important topic to be discussed, but why do these parents believe special needs children should go to a private school? Private schools are not supported by our tax dollars, so they are given the right to decide who can join their institutions and who can’t. People could think of it as college in that not every person who applies to a college is guaranteed to get in. All these parents are doing is retarding the work that private schools do with this argument. When a school requires acceptance to get in, instead of just basing the school on where a child lives, then they should be given the right to say yes or no to anyone. It’s not about how much money you make, it’s about how the school represents itself. These parents are attempting to change a long tradition of what schools will allow and not allow. Private schools probably don’t have special needs programs because tuition for these institutions is expensive enough as it is, without having to pay extra for the specific teachers and facilities that are needed for special needs children. Do these parents even consider the notion that maybe the next Einstein could be rejected from a private school because of his behavior? Probably not. Statistically speaking, regular tax-funded schools have higher grades and higher rates of student happiness. This is just my opinion.
If someone does not agree with my statements, then I am truly sorry.

By: LuckyDog on 3/14/13
I used to be very naive, and I believed that teachers unions would always have the best interests of the children in mind. Boy was I wrong. Teachers unions serve teachers, not children, and they will oppose anything that would allow a student to move from a public school to a private school because almost all unionized teachers teach at public schools. Captive students at public schools provide jobs for unionized teachers. If a poor student is stuck in a failing school, so be it. At least the unionized teachers will have jobs.

There's also one other issue that comes into play. Teachers unions have very liberal agendas, and they can indoctrinate students into their liberal ideology if the student is at a public school. If the student is allowed to move to a private school, they lose control of that child.


Login and voice your opinion!
Making Websites Easy Since 2001
Newspaper Software | Connect Email Marketing | Express Website Builder | WordPress Hosting