Join Us Box / Rack Advertise Service Contact Us
 
 
 
 
  Welcome Visitor, 519 members online. Date: Tue, Feb 9, 2010 My Account Login/Register  Search:   advanced  
Update: Disciplinary action announced by director of schools


 Related Articles
Email Print
Director of Schools Marilyn Mathis has suspended lead teacher, Quentin Mastin, and assistant principal, Don Bartch, for unprofessional conduct and neglect of duty due to actions taken with Scales Elementary School students on May 10, 2007 at Fall Creek Falls State Park. The suspension is without pay and will commence on May 14, 2007 and continue through the end of this school year ending June 1, 2007.


Gun prank punishment
Was the two week suspension of an assistant principal and a lead teacher adequate punishment in the Scales Elementary School "prank?"
Created Tuesday, May 15, 2007 10:02am

choice%#
Yes47.8%33
No44.9%31
Undecided2.9%2
total votes: 69
You must be logged in to cast a vote in this poll.
Share: 
Tags: None

Member Opinions:
By: OrangeCharlie on 5/15/07
Suspended? They should be fired!

By: JamieLynn on 5/15/07
Ms. Mathis acted appropriately. These teachers made a mistake, as we all have. Firing would have only hurt the students and the school.

OrangeCharlie- How blameless are you in this life?

By: nightwingoracle on 5/15/07
These teachers are responsible for educating young minds. They were also responsible for the these children's lives while they were away from home. They purposely terrorized the children and called it a prank. They should be fired and banned from teaching. Their actions are inexcusable. Their firings would help re-establish trust with the school and the school board. Keeping them only grows the distrust.

By: sja66 on 5/15/07
I believe the punishment to be appropriate. What I can't understand is the lynch mob mentality that exists. Does someone have to lose their job every single time a mistake is made? Have we fallen for the media's overusage of the word outrage?

By: nightwingoracle on 5/16/07
When you are entrusted to deal with children and you prove unworthy of that trust, yes, you should be removed from your position. It's not "lynch mob mentality." It's common sense.

By: GrumpaEd on 5/16/07
ZERO TOLERENCE?

Had this been a child's "prank" he/she would be gone from the student body. No ifs, ands nor buts.

By: BEVO on 5/16/07
With regards to the Scales elementary school "debacle" I can only state the following: it seems absolutely comical that people profess such a deep concern for the "safety" of children over a "prank" (albeit, a stupid, stupid choice by the individual) ; comical, yet pathetically sad. I am godsmacked, dumbfounded and absolutely stupefied by the hypocrisy of the outspoken Americans who rattle their cages at things so utterly meaningless and pride themselves over the mountains they create out of these molehills. Anyone with a functioning brain can readily state that this was a foolish decision on the part of the "authority figure" – what good is anyone accomplishing by stating the obvious, over and over again ? Truthfully, it was an abuse of the trust that children have towards their teachers. However, how can anyone in this nation leap on top of such a pretentious soapbox and highlight this exceedingly minor transgression while such horrible things are happening to children around this country 24 hours a day, 360 days out of the year ? This, unfortunately, is the sad reality of the mindset of Americans today. We are 100% brainwashed by the media into believing whatever they choose for us to not only hear and see but also to believe. How can all of these Americans turn a blind eye and deaf ear to the thousands of American youths (and adults, too) that die in our very own streets every year, shot, stabbed, beaten or otherwise murdered ? Where is the self-righteous outrage at this unnecessary death of America's youth ? Where are your voices when these kids need to hear that they can do better for themselves ? Where is the intense interest in the situation ? A deafening silence fills the air around this sober reality. It seems painfully evident that Americans don't care about anything more than what is in their oh-so-narrowly-defined everyday life. If American's don't live with it on a daily basis and personally experience it, then it is ignored and has no significance – at least not until it hits home.

Americans, thanks to the selective American media, spend a lot of time complaining about the stories that, in the grand scheme of things, are rather insignificant – this is only one example of many greater sad truths. Everyday, across the nation, more Americans are shot in our own towns than in the war in Iraq – where is the outrage for this ? These things are happening in our towns and communities and no one wants to lift a finger to better the situation, much less even acknowledge that it is happening. In my youth, I too walked around with the attitude that "it didn't concern me; I wasn't involved in it, I was being good, going to school, working to better myself". I ignored it, and it was easy to do so. But, with some age, I am increasingly aware of this sad reality - so much happens in this world that we don't hear about because American media has chosen for us to not hear it, so much so that we should all be screaming for new media outlets. What of the poor Africans who lost their arms and even their lives for no better reason that for women to wear diamonds around their fingers and necks ? While on the topic of Africa, why do we hear so much about Aids in Africa when the former Soviet Union has a much worse epidemic of Aids that is currently threatening to destroy an entire region there ? Where are the rock stars and reporters to bring attention to that painful reality ? Just yesterday, I was informed that Channel 4 reported that radioactive waste has been found in the Rutherford county landfill (is it true, perhaps not but I'd like to know) – where are the voices screaming and demanding that this be investigated and either confirmed and addressed or denied and proven false ? What will affect the development of the children more, an extremely poor choice of a joke, or radioactive pollutants in the drinking water ? This school administrator's bad choice, or the drugs and the weapons that follow them which are becoming more and more prevalent in American youth culture ? Is the choice you make going to be exaggerating the importance of this one stupid incident while at the same time teaching the children, through the actions they see performed by their parents, that this is what is far more important than the deaths in our streets ? What will you choose ?

I know that there will be very negative reaction to this message. People don't like to be reminded of these harsh truths – I don't like thinking about them either. But, they are there, every single day whether we want to admit it or not. It won't go away by ignoring it. I won't be returning to this to read the reviews or opinions that follow this because I didn't write it to see my own words or feel good about them, nor did I do it to stir up a controversy. I simply wanted to post the truth and hope that maybe someone will think about these things. Some will want to angrily deny what I wrote, but all that really matters, in the end, is can the truths be denied, can you disprove the facts as they are presented ? If so, then great for everyone, but facts, by their very nature, are what they are – absolute and irrefutable. Denying it won't bring back the dead; denying it won't undo the wrongs; denying it may make one feel better inside but what will that teach the children ? Take from it what you will; take none of it, even. We choose our actions daily and in doing so either permit things to continue as they are, or chose to act differently and make a change. Today, I chose to act.

By: Trvlace on 5/16/07
WOW! is that a book your writing? I think you put it in the wrong place. This was about some teachers who messed up and got busted for it. I don't see the tie in with Africa...and rock stars...or radioactive pollutants...

By: teachertoo on 5/16/07
As a teacher, I was shocked to hear that individuals in my profession would be as irresponsible and unthinking as to pull such a prank on a group of students. Our children have so many factors in life to worry about in today's world.(kidnappings, school shooters, rapist, etc.)They certainly do not need to have people in authoritative positions trying to place more fear in their minds. I am not professing to be the "perfect" role model, but I do resent the fact that teachers making bad decisions demean my profession on a daily basis. As usual, we all suffer because of the actions of few.

By: Paused on 5/16/07
Why did the survey change to busses with seatbelts?

By: DMW37128 on 5/16/07
Bevo, good point. Ashame parents / adults do not get as upset with child abuse and neglect as they are about this issue.

By: mikewest on 5/16/07
Paused...that was just one of those freak things. Thanks for calling it to our attention.

Mike West

By: deelew on 5/16/07
Bevo - holy cow?! That's definitely overboard - you have too much time on your hands.

Yes, this was a case of poor judgment. Yes, it crossed the line. How many of us remember a school moment from the past that impacted us? These teachers were NOT malicious in their acts. Stupid, yes - malicious, no. They got dealt a fair deal.

By: TimMartin on 5/16/07
Not commenting on the suspension. Instead on your vote question. The choices are not very well written. Yes and Undecided (Clear Enough). No (Are you really going to get a clear answer? A voter could answer NO meaning it was NOT ENOUGH or answer NO meaning it was TOO MUCH).

By: lcaffey on 5/16/07
*applause* Bevo. Well put if indeed a bit long-winded. But then again, sometimes you have to beat that dead cow quit a bit before some thicker heads let it sink in.

Let's get over this 'prank' already and get to taking care of some REAL issues!

By: saa on 5/16/07
Any of you know either of these guys, or work with them? Were any of you there when the alleged "terrorism" took place? No? Were any of you there for the PTO meeting the other night where parents voiced the opinion that these men shouldn't have been suspended? NO? Well, then stop the rhetoric, get out from in front of your computers, and go find out what is really going on in your community. Because as bevo pointed out, there's a lot more you could be getting involved with that is truly threatening to your children. Stop the madness people. I am outraged at your outrage. M'boro Post, do a follow-up on this "story" and find out what the parents and students of the school really think, not just the few who let their CHILDREN get in front of a television camera, which as a parent I would never do for many reasons, one of them being their safety!

By: prin on 5/16/07
I agree saa...It is time for us to hear / read from the other side of the issue...We only hear from a select few of parents / students that say they were scared. What about the rest of the 60 plus students that were there...Let us not be to judgemental too quick 'cause some day it might return and bite us in the butt...

By: Paused on 5/17/07
The PTO meeting is tonight. And the first news article that The Post had up on this was city school's own press release aka thier side.
No one has said thier children need therapy over this. But does that really make what happened "ok"?

By: keen on 5/17/07
Bevo, you give what amounts to a pass to these so called"educaters" and take issue wih he remainder of the living world. Did someone steal our soapbox?


Login and voice your opinion!